1939-40: Carl U. Smith (First Post Commander)
1940-41: Bernie E. Morris
1941-42: P.W. Lasater
1942-43: Earnest M. Katz
1943-44: Frank Gelish
1944-45: S.D. Griffin
1945-47: Hoke S. Highsmith
1947-49: E. Aiken Reagor (FL District 6 CDR 1953-54)
1949-50: William B. Jensen
1950-51: Claude Diz
1951-53: Marshal C. Peterson
1953-55: Don Chao
1955-56: John Mowat
1956-57: O.D. Howerlin
1957-59: Anthony J. Miller (FL District 6 CDR 1959-60)
1959-60: Israel Kaufman
1960-61: Ralph J. Haeffner
1961-62, 64-65, 66-67: Glendon E. Hawkins
1962-63: H.F. McCauslin
1963-64: Herbert H. Potter
1965-66: W.R. Thomas
1967-68: Otto Lodsdon
1968-69: William G. Orvis
1969-70: Henry H. Arabie
1970-74: Glen A. Edwards
1974-75: Lester G. Lamphier
1975-77, 80-81, 84-85: Paul T. Papevies (FL District 6 CDR 1977-79)
1977-78: Harold E. Briggs
1978-79, 86-87: Murray J. Finley
​1979-80: Jessie Magoner
1981-82: James L. Hennessy
1982-84: Douglas Martin
1985-86: Gary J. Harracks
1987-89: James P. Harris
1989-92: William C. Crabbs
1992-94: Sam A. Arnold
1994-95: Larry B. Tucker
1995-97: Chris M. Ellis 
1997-2000: Amphers J. Welch
2000-01: William E. Smith
2001-02: Robert Krepp
2002-08: Leland R. Fair* (FL District 6 CDR 2010-11)**
2008-09: Harvey K. Warnock
2009-10: Chris M. Ellis (FL District 6 CDR 1999-2000)
2010-12: Gary R. Sevick
2012-13: Doug Bagdasarian*
2013-15: James Durnal (FL District 6 CDR 2020-21)**
2015-17: Walter Fanton*
2017-18: Richard McDowell (FL District 6 CDR 2023-24)
2018-19: Donald Bulford
2019-21: Rich Possert Jr.* (FL District 6 CDR 2024-25)
2021-23: J.P. Culin*

2023-  : Bill Pugh*

 
* All-American Post Commander
** All-American District Commander